Samsung could emerge as the big winner from Huawei's miserable week (GOOG, INTC)


FILE PHOTO: A Samsung employee poses with the new Samsung Galaxy S10 5G smartphone at a press event in London, Britain February 20, 2019. REUTERS/Henry Nicholls

  • Huawei is Samsung’s biggest competitor in the worldwide smartphone market. But without Google’s Android, it could be difficult for Huawei to expand outside China.
  • This could make Samsung’s position at the top of the smartphone market all the more certain, leaving Apple as the only meaningful threat to its dominance.
  • If Huawei’s foldable smartphone, the Mate X, does not run on Google’s Android, it could make the device noticeably less appealing — therefore leaving an opportunity for Samsung to emerge as a leader in the foldable-phone market despite its rocky Galaxy Fold launch.
  • Visit Business Insider’s homepage for more stories.  

The biggest winner in the US government’s battle with China’s Huawei could turn out to be Samsung’s smartphones.

The South Korean tech giant has seen its perch at the top of the smartphone market threatened by Huawei’s surging tide of handhelds. And Samsung’s recent missteps in the rollout of its cutting-edge foldable phone, which was delayed because of quality problems, have added further uncertainty to Samsung’s reign.

But the Trump administration’s decision to put Huawei on a US trade blacklist could be the helping hand Samsung needs to retain its status as the world’s unrivaled smartphone superpower. 

The blacklist has forced tech companies such as Google and Intel to suspend business with Huawei. That means Huawei’s future phones will not be able to run on Google’s Android operating system, the most popular mobile software.

While Huawei says it has built its own homemade smartphone operating system that will be ready by next year, there’s no guarantee that consumers will buy Huawei phones if they have a new, unknown operating system, especially if that means the phones don’t have system-level access to popular Google services such as Gmail and Google Maps. 

That’s potentially good news for Samsung, which has been steadily losing market share to Huawei. In the first three months of 2019, Samsung accounted for 23.1% of the worldwide smartphone market, representing an 8.1% decrease from the year-ago period, according to the International Data Corp. Huawei’s position jumped 50% year-over-year to claim a 19% share of the market in the first quarter.

Besides Huawei, no other smartphone maker comes close to Samsung in terms of the global market share. Apple trailed in third place with 11.7% of the market in the first quarter, whereas the China-based smartphone maker Xiaomi ranked fourth with 8% of the market.

If Huawei sees a dip in smartphone sales as a result of these new US government requirements, rivals like Apple and Xiaomi would still have a lot of catching up to do in order to endanger Samsung’s spot at the top.

An Apple backlash in China

That’s not to say it’s impossible and that Samsung’s position at the top is guaranteed. The smartphone market often fluctuates between quarters based on a variety of factors, with Apple and Huawei usually switching back and forth to place in second behind Samsung. In the fourth quarter of 2018, for example, Apple held 18.2% of the worldwide smartphone market, coming very close to Samsung’s 18.7% lead. Huawei placed in third with 16.1% of the market — although its share grew by 43.9% year-over-year, while both Apple’s and Samsung’s declined.

Galaxy S10

But some analysts believe that the backlash against Huawei in the US could hurt Apple’s business in China. A team of analysts at UBS recently circulated a note citing the treatment of Huawei in the US as a potential risk to Apple, writing that nationalist sentiment has been known to sometimes affect foreign goods in China. People in China also recently called for a boycott of Apple’s products after the Trump administration’s decision to put Huawei on a trade blacklist, according to BuzzFeed News.

To be sure, Samsung’s smartphones do not have a strong presence in China, according to data from Counterpoint Research, which doesn’t even break out the Seoul-based tech giant in its ranking of the top smartphone vendors in the region.

But China is important for Apple’s business; it’s the company’s third-largest market, and the iPhone accounted for 12% of China’s smartphone market as of the fourth quarter of 2018, according to Counterpoint Research. If there is a boycott against Apple products in China, it could make it more difficult for the company to broaden the iPhone’s reach and catch up to Samsung’s global market share.

The folding-phone debacle

There’s another key way Samsung could stand to benefit from Huawei’s misfortunes when it comes to the smartphone space: foldable phones. Samsung’s Galaxy Fold got off to a rocky start to say the least after small number of reviewers reported that the device’s screen had broken, prompting Samsung to indefinitely delay the Fold’s launch. Samsung still hasn’t said when the phone would be released.

huawei mate x smaller photo size

But the new restrictions Huawei faces when working with US companies could give Samsung’s Galaxy Fold a second chance.

Huawei unveiled its Mate X foldable phone just days after Samsung debuted the Fold in February, showcasing an impressively designed device with a crease that appeared to be less noticeable than the one found on Samsung’s phone. Huawei hasn’t announced when the phone would be released yet, making it unclear whether or not it will be able to run on Google’s Android software. The US government has granted Huawei a 90-day reprieve that allows it to maintain and support its products until August 19. But we don’t know if the Mate X will launch before then, although a report from GizmoChina suggested it could be released in June.

Losing Android would be a tough blow for Huawei, but it’s especially damaging for a device as expensive as the Mate X, which will be priced at around $2,600 when it launches. For shoppers outside of China, not having Google’s widely popular suite of services and its enormous app store could drastically lower the Mate X’s value proposition should it not run on Google’s software. There’s also the concern as to whether or not the software on Huawei’s Mate X will be as feature-rich and polished as foldable phones that run on Google’s Android, considering the search giant has tailored the next version of Android to make it adaptable to foldable form factors.

Samsung Fold

Of course, Huawei and Samsung are not the only companies working on foldable devices. Xiaomi and Motorola are developing foldable phones of their own, but neither of those products seem as far along as those made by Samsung and Huawei. That could leave Samsung with an opportunity to own the nascent foldable-smartphone market for a considerable amount of time should it relaunch the Galaxy Fold in the near future.

It’s too soon to know precisely what will happen to Huawei as a result of the US government’s recent trade sanctions. The company has said it has been working on its own operating system to replace Android, and Ren Zhengfei, the company’s CEO, recently told the Nikkei Asian Review that he expects the company’s growth to slow only a little bit. But even if Zhengfei proves to be correct, and Huawei’s growth only mildly slows, that’s still bound to be good news for Samsung’s reign over the global smartphone market.  

SEE ALSO: Trump’s Huawei ban may leave the tech giant up a creek without a paddle for its next 2 major smartphones

Join the conversation about this story »

NOW WATCH: I tried the $1,980 Samsung Galaxy Fold and it’s impressive for a first-generation foldable phone, though far from perfect